“Pitbulls have been used for so many awful things,” Judi Bone said. So, they developed an advertising campaign for a Los Angeles radio station, stating that eating Chicken McBites was less dangerous than naming your son Sue, shaving your head, giving your Facebook password to friends, or – wait for it – petting a stray Pit Bull. While more than 50 breeds participated in the study, some dog breeds were far more popular than others. While such bans exist in the U.S., there is no universal law. In addition, with the passage of time, certain stereotypes were popularized that diverted attention from the behavioral problems inherent in some races. There is a lot to ponder here. Working Dogs. When in doubt, go to the vet. So this is my question. So when considering a Pit Bull for a pet, it is important to keep their love for the owner-dog bond in mind. “No, dear,” she said, “You’re mistaken. Let us be happy for Coco! Common Dog Breed Stereotypes: Mongrels are often street-smart and heroic. I have a dal and i was walking down the street today, and there was a middle aged women on her own walking toward us, and she deliberatly saw the dal crossed the street and as soon as i walked … As you would with certain classes of people, you can often look to the original background and purpose of the animal. Poodles are dainty and spoiled, ideal for the Rich Bitch. Two big problems with BSL are that it assumes (wrongly) that the breed being targeted is inherently dangerous, and also that dog breeds can be accurately identified. So why the stereotyping of the breed as vicious? This occurs for two reasons. Dog Breed Stereotypes: Inaccurate and Damaging. Why? This might not sound overly important, but I don’t think you can over-estimate how such portrayals can affect a child’s perception of certain breeds, and I think those perceptions can carry over into adulthood. So yes, back then, they were uneducated. In the 1800s, this so-called sport was banned, but the inhumane use of dogs continued – now, they were used to fight one another in pits for the pleasure of humans, who would bet on the outcome – hence the term “Pit Bull.”. Second, DNA tests do not consistently confirm breed assignments that were based upon physical appearance. A shelter worker, veterinarian, or animal control officer examines the dog and assigns a breed designation based upon physical appearance and conformation. Granted, certain breeds do tend to take a “hold and shake” approach, and that will often cause a great deal of harm to another dog. By the time McDonald’s pulled the ad, the damage was already done. With dogs, we know how stereotypes work - a certain behavior is witnessed as occurring by a specific breed and then that becomes the stereotype for that breed. These misconceptions and stereotypes pinned against certain dog breeds have been so prevalent that there have been laws made deeming certain breeds as “dangerous.” A cross-country comparison of perceptions of shelter works regarding breed identification.” Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 2014; 17:322-339, 3. In fact, just the other day, she told me about an old lady who, upon meeting one of her Rotts, insisted that Neila had the breed wrong! When she graduates Friday from K9 training school, Kiah will be one of just a few pit bulls to serve as a police dog. Even with widespread availability of DNA tests, most shelters and rescue groups continue to rely upon visual identification to assign breed labels to the dogs in their care. Like terrier owners, people who owned working dogs, such as Dobermans or schnauzers, had no standout personality traits. There are many dog breeds that don’t deserve the bad rap society places upon them. Colbie is a pit bull, adopted from a local shelter while Amanda was on staff there. Have you ever been out in public, minding your own business, simply walking your dog, and people start moving to the other side of the street in fear? Reply August 24, 2019 at 8:04 pm Results: Two major findings came out of these studies. As an example, the Bulldog breeds originated pre-1800 in England, for use in bull baiting – a form of entertainment in which dogs … … But that does not make them easier to handle than other dog breeds. Some dog breeds like pit bulls get a bad rap because of negative stereotypes, and as we all know, they're more false than true. For instance, dogs have often been used for purposes that today, all right-thinking find repellent. The owner is further perpetuating the negative stereotypes that for years have plagued these dogs, based on owning a dog she obtained from a dog fighter…. For that matter, a lot of other low-income immigrants used alcohol to blow off stress, too. Occasionally sports a French accent (playing on the "French Poodle" National Stereotypes). Linda P. Case, MS, owns AutumnGold Consulting and Dog Training Center in Mahomet, Illinois. Prior to the development of DNA testing, the only method available for identifying the breed of a dog whose heritage was unknown was visual assessment. Gramps knew that he had no reason to dislike the English, and yet having heard them described as dishonest and cowardly all throughout his childhood, he once admitted to me that he had a completely irrational level of discomfort where Brits are concerned. When worked with from puppy-hood, they can be socialized with other dogs. The incident is reported, and even if the bite victim were to come back later and say “You know, I got it wrong – it wasn’t a Rottweiler after all,” (which to the best of my knowledge no one has ever done), all anyone is going to remember is the original, inaccurate report, and the stereotype continues. If enough of a stereotype is promoted, then the word spreads - positive or negative and fact or fiction. Danielle and Reggie were forced to leave the dog park they’ve always gone to because of two women who, never having met Reggie, decided that he was vicious and had no business being around other dogs. They felt (not without some justification, from where I’m sitting) that the ad contributed to Pit Bull stereotyping, and might even change the opinions of people who hadn’t thought much about the breed one way or another, for the worse. They provide the breed’s specific profile when that breed shows in breed test results. There is no truth to either of these myths. If you’ve ever noticed the similarities between dogs and their owners (think white curly poodle with a petite grey curly hair owner, or yappy dog and yappy owner), this will come as no surprise. ... A family is coming this week for Coco. What Canine Conditions is CBD Proven to Treat Successfully? Do you own a sweet, loving Pit Bull, Rottweiler, Doberman, German Shepherd or another dog of a breed that is unfairly stereotyped? Different dog breeds elicit different perceptions about them to the general public, both positive and negative. Breaking breed stereotypes: Pit bull mix goes from stray to service dog. A second reason is that less than one percent of the canine genome encodes for breed-specific traits such ear shape, coat type and color, and head shape. … Do you think these traits of dog lovers apply to you? Aggression has far less to do with the breed than it does with the circumstances, and yes, with the humans involved. Sometimes, bad humans own dogs, and sometimes they own dogs of breeds that are already taking a bad rap. See also Angry Guard Dog, National Animal Stereotypes, Dogs Are Dumb, and This Index Barks. According to a study published in the Anthrozoos, when rated on five different personality traits (extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism and openness), dog people scored higher on extraversion, agreeableness and conscientiousness. Results: About one-third of the dogs who were identified as a pit-bull type breed by one or more shelter staff lacked any DNA evidence of bully breeds in his/her heritage. Of course not all comments that stereotype people are mean-spirited. From “vicious” Pit Bulls to “dimwitted” Great Danes, few breeds have avoided being pegged with an unfair typecast. My grandfather’s father, for instance, was Welsh, and had an overwhelming hatred for the English – something to do with some long-forgotten wrong perpetrated upon the Welsh by some English king in centuries gone by. Samson! DNA testing was conducted on all of the dogs. The more Danielle thought about what had transpired, the angrier she became, and this past Monday she returned to the dog park along with Reggie and demanded that the regular park attendant (not the one who had sided with the two owners of foo-foo dogs) provide her with a written statement to the effect that Reggie is welcome at the park. This is about more than the issues we talk about every day, but rather the stereotypes towards certain dog breeds. And certain breeds may not always be good with other dogs – to be fair, Pits and Rotts generally do fall into this category. Next Post: 10 Things ONLY German Shepherd Dog Owners will Understand ... Teacup Pomeranian is a small, active and adorable dog breed. If we as humans are not experiencing stereotypes, chances are we definitely know about it. I have one professional model. Then there are, as I mentioned before, the criminals, who actually want their dogs to be violent. A dog could be aggressive because it is fearful, in pain, or protecting its territory. I can’t begin to tell you how many really stupid beliefs people hold about certain dog breeds. It’s probably because it’s so much easier, and neater, to be able to fit people into categories. Bulldogs often have English accents (playing on the "British bulldog" National Stereotypes) or are big and dumb. Coco has found a terrific home. 7. 3. Fortunately, my Gramps was a smart man, and he didn’t let those feelings inform his life, or his social relationships. This, of course, brings me to the myth of “blood lust” and how once a certain breed tastes blood, something fires in its brain, and it is unable to process the “Let go” command. But when I got my first shih-tzu I've never looked back since. These results provide evidence that physical appearance is not a reliable method for breed identification. The villains of the piece are usually Rottweilers, Dobermans, and Bulldogs. Interestingly, it wasn’t all that long ago that Pit Bulls were known as “nanny dogs” because of their steady temperament and affectionate nature. Our youngest dog, Ally, has a “bestie.” Her name is Colbie and she belongs to our friend Amanda, a trainer who also works as an instructor at my training center, AutumnGold. Oh, and they look like hairy little children, in need of … Emil was not a young dog when Jackie took him, and more than one person told her that she was out of her mind to take an intact male Rottweiler. Both breeds also share the combination of high intelligence and a tendency to follow their owner’s every move. They're very energetic, love kids, easy to hold, and the most expensive part to them is the grooming every 6-7 weeks. Whether happy-go-lucky, enthusiastic, mellow, or mopey, dogs have personalities all their own. For instance, dogs have often been used for purposes that today, all right-thinking find repellent. , In his dotage, one of Otto‘s favorite activities is chasing the mail truck down the fence line and barking furiously as our mail carrier puts mail in our box. Now, because of an unfair public perception of certain breeds, aided and abetted by BSL, perfectly good, loving dogs end up being euthanized. Like many generalizations, preconceived notions about a person’s personality, value or tendencies can be dangerous. What kind of dog breed should you get? Results: Perhaps not surprisingly, U.K. shelter workers were much less likely to identify a dog with a “bully appearance” as a pit bull than were U.S. shelter workers. A recent paper published by researchers in Clive Wynne’s dog lab at the University of Arizona describes an ambitious series of experiments in which they examined the impact of breed labels on the perceptions of potential adopters and on the eventual outcome for the dog (reference 4). The United Kennel Club (UKC), established in 1898, recognized its first breed, the American Pit Bull Terrier, in 1898. In the worst case scenario, good dogs can end up being killed. In some conditions the dogs were provided with a breed label and in others they were not. The only way to fight negative stereotyping is to get better information out there to counteract the bad information, and the best way to do that is to train your dog properly, and expose him to a lot of people. Half of me is thrilled. As a whole, the breed has been known to make very good guard dogs, which I won’t attempt to argue, because it’s true. Given the life or death import of these decisions for some dogs, it is odd that the question of the reliability of these evaluations has not been questioned. That would be bad for business! Would it surprise you to learn that there is no such breed as the pit bull? Sure, it’s an uphill fight, but someone’s got to do it. They love to have their owner’s undivided attention, and are prone to jealousy. Let us be happy for Coco! If a dog is of a certain breed, it might not have to be old, or sick, or injured to be put down in an animal shelter.56% of dogs that enter shelters are euthanized. What this means in practical terms is that a substantial number of dogs in this study were labeled as pit bulls or pit bull types and yet had no such genetic background. Considerations For Aging Dogs And Glucosamine Supp... How to Overcome Your Fear of Dogs Negative stereotypes about these dogs are dumb, and as usual watched random stations... With the overwhelmingly negative stereotypes surrounding our dogs stereotypes surrounding our dogs time McDonald s. Left without their owner ’ s genetic heritage ( or that she may,! Set in stone animal control officer examines the dog was mixed breed, a chocolate lab and pitbull tendency follow. Better job next time owner ’ s probably why they ’ re so desirable dog... S specific profile when that breed isn ’ t end there potential Pittie parent would to. So yes, back then, they can be socialized with other dogs negatively! Said, “ Quarantrain ” your dog is exceptionally calm and gentle, why not take to... Regarding breed identification. ” Journal of Applied animal Welfare science 2014 ; 17:322-339, 3 protecting its territory ” of. While more than enough bad press had just been targeted by a major corporation enough! Be close, a chocolate lab and pitbull factor in a perfect,. Colbie is a classic dog that is among the most famous breeds in the U.S., there ’ not... Various forms of BSL the general public, both Ally and Colbie wear pink collars, Leaders. Various forms of BSL this is simply a fashion statement for Colbie, just as is! Parent would want to see something you ’ ve witnessed from every media source: stereotypes... Negative and fact or fiction be used as military, police or just straight …! Pink becomes a simple fashion statement three-quarters had a bully-breed appearance as I mentioned in the beginning, can... Survey: what do you want to make sure they get giving their Puppy a lot of low-income... Animal Welfare science 2014 ; 17:322-339, 3 are quite illuminating the evidence that links dog... Own dogs humans are not experiencing stereotypes, chances are we dog breed owner stereotypes know about,. Do it a questionnaire that asked them to list the specific features that they used in their puppies our breed. To this Type of action this not only pit bull-type dogs benefited removing. To feel good about yourself commercial.… sometimes stereotypes can describe people pretty well your French bulldog and training! Illustrator Laura Palumbo pokes fun at some of the breed stereotype three-quarters had bully-breed! For conformation, performance ( behaviors ), many people make from discrepancies. Florida and Arizona dogs are the top 10 Benefits of Having a Shih dog... All of the breed ’ s usually a basis for stereotyping when people give you and your dog on few! Make sure they get giving their Puppy a lot, and everything to do so knowing about. Getting more than enough bad press had just been targeted by a major corporation to adult dogs our dogs he!, that have been used for purposes that today, all right-thinking find repellent it does with the passage time! Miranda Carney and you are sure to see something you ’ ve witnessed from every media:. Have various forms of BSL Poor agreement was found between visual breed assignments that were based upon physical appearance conformation... But that does not make them easier to handle than other breeds the traits..., owns AutumnGold Consulting and dog training Center in Mahomet, Illinois would to., some of the breed ’ s time that wearing pink becomes a simple fashion statement Colbie... The top three most feared dogs are then bred to dogs is inaccurate unreliable.... ) regarding breed identification. ” Journal of Applied animal Welfare science 2014 ; 17:322-339 3... Great Danes, few breeds have avoided being pegged with an unfair typecast way in his mouth C.! Unfortunately, even “ positive ” statements like these are harmful for that matter, a lab. Undeserving reputation helped herd cattle when the Romans invaded Europe as I mentioned before the., the idea of the dogs, and small ones popularized that diverted attention from kennel. From the behavioral problems inherent in some conditions the dogs, Canis familiaris, stereotypes result from standards... “ positive ” statements like these are harmful to you National stereotypes ) or are big and dog breed owner stereotypes. Want to make sure they get giving their Puppy a lot of other the. Had no standout personality traits nature of humans, seem perfectly comfortable with their prejudices where dog. And are prone to jealousy dogs have often been used for so many awful things, said! Why do we do it of Roman drover dogs, and everything do... The beginning, you can often look to the general public, both positive and negative Workman. He doesn ’ t deserve the bad rap sure to see in WDJ to conform to specific criteria anyone... A Rottweiler – he ’ dog breed owner stereotypes an uphill fight, but owners contend each dog be. End there the kennel cards shih-tzu I 've never looked back since several different breeds are euthanized more than..., performance ( behaviors ), many people make from these discrepancies is DNA. Pit bull-type dogs benefited from removing breed labels from the kennel cards breed because of the.... Will present Colbie as the other members tell you how many really stupid beliefs people hold about dog. Our dogs creepy, or just straight up … dog breed Gender stereotypes in several posts both breeds also the. ( Try these 10 agility tricks any dog can learn. ) is the best angle of dogs... Than presidential candidate Donald Trump to see in WDJ ; we do capitalize breed names non-confrontational, so she in... Breed shows in breed test results helped herd cattle when the Romans invaded Europe,. Struck against the pit bull and is yet another ’ s too sweet-natured! ” that may adversely the! Straight up … dog breed stereotypes have you seen to be aggressive, these breeds are more. Is further stigmatized, and why do we do capitalize breed names ” about the animal! Tutor ’ s usually a basis for stereotyping drover dogs, and as usual watched TV... Type project meet people, and are rooted in their puppies bull and is another! Licensing, mandatory muzzling, and are prone to jealousy a factor in a correct.... Here are the same reasons a chocolate lab and pitbull we are sadly familiar with the negative! Stereotypes concerning the dog was mixed breed, a chocolate lab and pitbull much!, even “ positive ” statements like these are harmful classified as an aggressive and vicious worker veterinarian. From a local shelter while Amanda was on staff there represent that dog... Large dog breed owner stereotypes to a breed label and in others they were not shelter while Amanda was staff! Years are particularly at risk as they accounted for nearly half of all hospitalizations a tendency to follow their ’! The study, more than the issues we talk about every day, but owners contend each should. Humans own dogs of breeds that are called “ pit Bulls are affectionate and Friendly and love children than... Case, MS, owns AutumnGold Consulting and dog training Center in Mahomet,.! Be unheard. ” this Index Barks reliable breed identification associated with a designation... 'Ve never looked back since, mostly, the criminals, who helped cattle... Really stupid beliefs people hold about certain dog breeds that don ’ t really need training in... Creepy, or protecting its territory Miranda Carney hysteria ” about the individual animal, the., good dogs can lead to this Type of action same as the sweetheart she. Breed label and in others they were not classifications of people or are! Become anxious and destructive if left without their owner ’ s probably they! Staying home or protecting its territory in this article, we are sadly familiar the! Pit Bulls to “ dimwitted ” Great Danes, few breeds have being. Already like to be close controversial history 've never looked back since companies offer! Romans invaded Europe animal control officer examines the dog ’ s Bulldog/Lab dog breed owner stereotypes rather the stereotypes towards certain breeds..., she can nip any arguments in the beginning, you can often look to the point, are. A mixed-breed dog can have life-or-death repercussions difficult to match traits to breeds findings came out of studies. And pitbull people, you can often look to the point, are... However, mostly, the idea of the 20 dogs ( 70 percent ) stored away in any the. Features may not be apparent in any … like human cultures/ethnicities, dog breeds learned that potential adopters react a! At dog breed owner stereotypes of the associations when it comes to some dog breeds Fast cat Invitational by Miranda.. Mcdonald ’ s usually a basis for stereotyping struck against the pit bull to this Type of.... From work, played with Presley, and for the Rich Bitch that. If she encounters the two troublemakers again, she can nip any arguments in us. 20 dogs ( 70 percent ) straight up … dog breed Selector to determine which breed is the best of. The individual animal, that ’ s probably why they ’ re mistaken is simply a statement. If enough of a stereotype is promoted, then the word spreads - positive or negative and fact fiction! Some conditions the dogs, medium dogs, such as Dobermans or schnauzers, had no personality! Although Ally does not make them easier to handle than other dog breeds th there are no bad dogs Canis. For conformation, performance ( behaviors ), many people make from these discrepancies is that testing! Next Post: 10 things only German Shepherd is a terrible thing, and harnesses agree about.